But no does have to, as you said there is plenty of free stuff on youtube and forums for those who prefer not to but if anyone would like to, they can and there isn't anything wrong with that.

I'm pretty sure Scott pays or paid for a subscription to Phil's site/videos and says it's a good value for the money.

People don't have to pay for skating lessons, or guitar lessons, or sculpting lessons, or skiing lessons but it sure does help some people advance well in their chosen hobby to a point where they can enjoy it in the way they like.

No one should have to pay for modeling videos in the same way that no one should have to give away their talents/skills for free.